Menu
Back to News

Update on New Mexico guide shoot-out


Presidio County Sheriff Danny Dominguez during the investigation on Saturday.
Photo credits: BigBendNow.com

Edit: There has been an update to the story and the two hunters have been indicted in a shooting they falsely claimed was started by unauthorized immigrants. Stay tuned for a full update on this case.

New information has surfaced regarding the New Mexico guide shoot-out in Candelaria, TX. While goHUNT previously reported that the shooting was thought to be an attack by illegal immigrants targeting the hunting party, it appears that might not be the case according to officials. In fact, Texas police officers have urged those involved not to talk about the incident as the investigation continues.

According to NewsWest9.com, the only bullet casings found at the scene of the crime by Texas authorities “belonged to the individuals hunting in the ranch.” Following the 911 call, the entire Circle Dug Ranch was searched by 30 U.S. Border Patrol agents, who concluded that there was no sign of outside traffic to or from the ranch; the shooting appears to be a result of “friendly fire” gone wrong.

“We’re still investigating and waiting for ballistics results from [Texas Department of Public Safety] lab in El Paso,” Presidio County Sheriff’s Deputy Joel Nuñez told Big Bend Now. “Right now, there is no evidence to suggest there was any ‘cross-border violence’ situation there.”

According to Nuñez, “the story is similar to what the 911 caller told dispatch and what witnesses told law enforcement during preliminary interviews,” but investigators do not have any evidence that suggests the crime is “cross border violence.” In fact, Texas officials believe that the final report on the ballistic evidence submitted to the Department of Public Safety Crime Lab in El Paso, TX will link the projectiles to the weapons used by the hunters themselves.

The following is a statement released by the family:

"The family of Walker Daugherty has decided to release a statement regarding their version of the events that took place on a rural TX ranch along the Mexico border on January 6th. Our statement comes after the Presidio County Sheriff, Danny Dominguez issued what he described as his office’s conclusion to their investigation of the incident. In an interview with reporters, Sheriff Dominguez declared that there was no cross-border activity and the incident “was the result of friendly fire.” We have chosen to release an account of events leading up to the incident to clear up, what they feel is, a lot of misinformation being reported.

Sheriff Dominguez’s statement that there has been “no indication of cross border activity” on the ranch is inaccurate. The truth is we [have] been involved in numerous incidents of cross border activity on the Circle Dug Ranch since December. The first involving a group of illegals we spotted and kept track of until Border Patrol arrived in a helicopter and captured them. The 2nd capture was the result of a break-in and robbery of our camp while we were out hunting. The following day we located a group of illegals with our spotting scopes and called Border Patrol. They came with the helicopter and captured them. They turned out to be the robbers and we recovered some of our stolen property. One of the robbers was a convicted felon who just got out of prison in KS, MO. This was his fourth capture. On another occasion two men from El Salvador came into camp and we held them until Border Patrol arrived. On yet another occasion we witnessed an illegal breaking into a neighboring ranch house, who we reported and Border Patrol caught him. All of this does not take into account the regular sightings of illegal’s foot tracks and their evidence that we see all the time. Border Patrol told us that everyone should be armed and never travel alone.

The incident that took place on January 6th revolves around a failed robbery attempt of the hunter client's RV and the response of Walker and Michael to the perceived threat. A statement by the client indicates that they were awakened by voices and someone repeatedly attempting to gain entry into their RV. Walker heard the attack from his room in the ranch house, woke Michael and both responded. Shots were fired and the hunter and Walker were both wounded.

The incident was not the result of miscommunication or reckless gun handling. We do not deny that the client was hit by friendly fire but Walker was not! We cannot at this time reveal all details but what we can say is we do not agree with the Sheriff's statement. Our experience has come into question but we have been professionally guiding hunters for 40 years. We have also assisted state game agency in the apprehension of numerous poaching cases and violations. For a period of time I worked as a reserve conservation officer for NMDGF. We know our surroundings, our firearms and our occupation. What took place on that night was extremely rare and will probably never happen again, but if it does we are prepared!"

Despite the information, Walker Daugherty still remains in the hospital due to his injuries in the shoot-out. If you want to donate to his medical care, visit www.gofundme.com/help-for-walker-daugherty. Stay tuned to goHUNT for more information on the case as it is released.


This article was edited to add the family's statement.
 

 

 

8 Comments

Log in or register to post comments.

Dennis B. - posted 2 years ago on 02-19-2017 11:37:20 pm
Alaska

Yo Murray, concerning your previous FAKE NEWS and get the TRUTH comments.......your gonna need a bigger wall.

murray p. - posted 2 years ago on 01-22-2017 01:37:35 pm
rehoboth beach, de
goHUNT INSIDER

Brady.. MT has a special place in my heart. It was hard to leave. Fortunately, my wife and i are able to get back most falls for elk season.... Its a good break for us to regroup after a busy summer. Seems like you have a good gig In NV. i have only heard good things from my buddies that live there.. Good hunting opportunities they say. keep an eye out for me on a good whitetail outfitter and keep up the good work on the mule deer killing. THANKS!

Brady J. Miller
Brady M. - posted 2 years ago on 01-22-2017 12:18:43 pm
Las Vegas, NV
goHUNT Team

I definitely will. Thanks! I was talking to them last week. On a separate note... when did you move out of Montana? It was tough for me to leave Montana.

murray p. - posted 2 years ago on 01-22-2017 12:13:24 pm
rehoboth beach, de
goHUNT INSIDER

Brady, thanks for your response. Reach out to the family one more time.. I think they have some new info.

Brady J. Miller
Brady M. - posted 2 years ago on 01-20-2017 10:53:49 am
Las Vegas, NV
goHUNT Team

Hi Murray P. - We covered both sides of the story in this article. You will see about that we included their part of the story. As a news source we have to cover both parts of every story. Glad you had a great hunt with them. Also, we first covered thier story right when we heard about it. You can read that here: https://www.gohunt.com/read/news/new-mexico-hunting-guide-and-client-shot-near-mexico-border

Hope you have a great day!

murray p. - posted 2 years ago on 01-20-2017 04:58:22 am
rehoboth beach, de
goHUNT INSIDER

FAKE NEWS..... Contact the family and get the TRUTH... If anyone on here has actually hunted and spent time with the Daugherty family, you would know that character is not an issue. Make sure you ask the family and BP how many assisted arrest they have been involved with in the last year in particular area. Do better research Gohunt... They are a top notch guide service THAT YOU RECOMMEND TO ME via a NM Elk tag. I had a very successful hunt with them last November and i can't get back fast enough.

http://www.judicialwatch.org/blog/2017/01/border-patrol-alters-stats-hid...

Dennis B. - posted 2 years ago on 01-16-2017 06:44:39 pm
Alaska

Mo......
1) L.E. to participants..." What intoxicants were used prior to this incident?"

2) Guides to Client-Hunters..."Thanks for the (bullet) tip, but I prefer hundred dollar bills."

3) Client-Hunters to Contracting Guide-Outfitter..."After we paid for a full hunt, and in view of this shortened hunt, do we get to return next year for free?"

4) Contracting Guide-Outfitter to his crew of assistants..."Following the exponential increase of the required guide insurance, it appears we are now out of business!"

Mo, anyone?

Dennis B. - posted 2 years ago on 01-16-2017 02:24:39 pm
Alaska

How od for hunters and guides to find yet another way to "shoot themselves in the foot", or wherever. The final report should be fascinating. Appears the damn desperados were themselves.